Article Productivity of CCJ Doctoral Programs

Which criminology and criminal justice doctoral programs’ faculty publish the most refereed articles, and in which journals? This dashboard extends a series of studies that began with Kleck, Wang, and Tark (2007), continued with Kleck and Barnes (2011), and most recently Kleck and Mims (2017). It covers the 44 member programs of the Association of Doctoral Programs in Criminology and Criminal Justice.

Every number on this page is recomputed in your browser from article-level data. Change the years, the weighting, the journals counted, or the faculty included, and the rankings, charts, and article list all update. The address bar keeps your settings, so you can share any view by copying the link.

The default settings reproduce the published rankings. The other settings are for exploration: they are not the paper’s method, and small differences between neighboring programs rarely mean much (see How the numbers work below).

Loading dashboard data...

How the numbers work

Who counts. Regular faculty (assistant, associate, and full professors, plus research professors) listed on each program’s website, following Kleck and Mims (2017). Faculty whose principal appointment is in another department are excluded. Credit follows the person: a faculty member’s articles count for their current program, even when the work was done elsewhere. Faculty who could not be matched to a publication record stay in their program’s denominator with zero credit.

What counts. Refereed, English-language articles in journals, assigned to the year of the issue they appear in (not the year they were posted online). Publications come from OpenAlex, with Crossref for issue years and author order. Namesake articles, editorials, book reviews, and similar items were removed by hand review.

Credit. Each faculty authorship earns a byline weight (sole author 1.0; first of two .60, second .40; first of three .40, then .35 and .25; with four or more authors, .40 for the first and .60 split among the rest) times a journal weight: the journal’s prestige rating from Sorensen, Snell, and Rodriguez (2006), a calibrated rating from Sorensen, Patterson, and Widmayer (1992), or 4 for unrated journals. Two faculty from the same program on one article each earn their own credit.

How much to trust it. The automated counts miss some articles and include a few that do not belong, so treat gaps of a rank or two between neighboring programs as noise. Credit-per-faculty rankings are especially sensitive for small programs, where one prolific scholar can carry the whole program.

Updates. New years are added after each data refresh, and every refresh is reviewed by hand before it appears here. Because rosters are refreshed too, numbers for earlier years can shift when faculty move between programs.

The data and code behind this page are archived on Zenodo and available on GitHub. The preprint and the published paper will be linked here.

Found a mistake?

With more than 700 faculty and 5,000 articles, there will be some. If you find one, please tell me using the form below. Every report gets a decision, and every correction appears in the release notes above.

What I will correct: an article credited to the wrong person (a namesake), a missing article, a credited item that is not a refereed research article (an editorial, book review, review report, or interview), an article assigned to the wrong issue year, or a faculty member wrongly counted or left out under the rules above.

What I will log but not change on request: disagreements with the rules themselves, such as counting books, crediting articles to the program where the work was done, or a different authorship weighting. These are fair debates, and the settings above let you see how much they matter. Rule changes, if any, would apply to every program at once in a future release.

What helps: a DOI or link for each article, and for faculty questions, a link to a vita or the program’s faculty page. Reports are reviewed in batches, usually within two weeks, and corrections appear in the next release.