Review of "Cops, Cameras, and Crisis"

Review of "Cops, Cameras, and Crisis"

Abstract

In this book, Michael White and Aili Malm review the benefits and limitations of police body-worn cameras (BWCs), with an eye toward their potential to increase transparency, accountability, and legitimacy. Key outcomes assessed include perceived procedural justice, use of force, complaints, criminal investigations, and officer activity (i.e., stops, citations, arrests, proactivity). They conclude that the body of evidence is promising: BWCs can be effective if implemented properly and expectations are managed.

Publication
Theoretical Criminology

It’s pretty remarkable that evaluation research has kept pace with the proliferation of BWCs in policing. At this moment, there are at least 100 peer-reviewed studies that evaluate their effects on policing. It shouldn’t surprise anyone that some have uncovered significant improvements and some have not. Not all BWC programs are created equally. Evaluation studies vary in terms of their scientific rigor. And frankly, some of the anticipated benefits of BWCs were unrealistic in the first place.

Anyway, if you’re interested in how BWCs have changed policing, read this book. If you’re interested in the perils as well as the potentials associated with BWCs, read this book. And if you’re of the general mindset that policing should be informed by scientific evidence, read this book. It’s a good one, and at ~140 pages, it’s easy to get through in just a few sittings.

Finally, interested readers should also check out this recent meta-analysis of 30 experimental and quasi-experimental BWC evaluations by Cynthia Lum and colleagues.

Click on the PDF button above to download a post-print copy of my review.
Avatar
Justin Nix
Associate Professor of Criminology and Criminal Justice

My research interests include police legitimacy, procedural justice, and officer-involved shootings.